In many cases the 40 year amortized loan will have a better
rate than an interest only payment. If the 40 year payment
is just slightly higher than the interest only payment,
opt for the 40 year payment because you will be paying down
some principal.
The 40-Year Mortgage allows for principal reduction but
at a significant lower payment to borrower. The difference
in payments can be pretty significant. For example, on a
$500,000 mortgage financed over 30 years at a fixed rate
of 5.875% costs $2957.69 a month. But the monthly principle
and interest payment drops $2707.63 on a 40-year schedule.
That is over $250 less in your monthly payment.
One of the disadvantages of a 40 year loan is that the
homeowner builds equity at a much slower pace. For first-time
buyers counting on equity accumulation to eventually move
up to another, larger and more expensive home, this slower
pace of equity accumulation is a liability and may leave
some people sadly disappointed.
For renters who cannot afford a 30-year mortgage and still
want to own their own homes, a 40-year amortization mortgage
is often a good solution. In many metropolitan areas, the
average rental cost for a single family residence is about
the same as the monthly payments of a 40-year amortization
mortgage with conforming loan amounts. Renters in these
areas can often afford their own homes afterall. However
slow homeowners with 40-year mortgages build equity, they
do contribute to the equity of their own home nonetheless.
If you run the numbers using a mortgage calculator you
will be able to see the benefits of homeownership vs. renting.